My Pet Theory: Parallels Between Breaking Bad and Boardwalk Empire
By Sam
Note: if you’re not caught up on either show, skip this article. Spoilers.
This is My Pet Theory, a column I’m inventing just so I can write this article. Maybe it’ll continue. Who knows. To the crux: Breaking Bad and Boardwalk Empire are, without a doubt, two of the finest dramas ever to grace the small screen. Perfectly plotted, with excellent, hardworking casts and some of the best cinematography this side of Emmanuel Lubezki, they exist as a testament to the art of television.
They’re also the same exact show.
That’s not anything against either show. In fact, they compliment each other beautifully. But there’s no question in my mind that Walter White and Nucky Thompson are (unintentionally) the same character, and the worlds around them are very similar, if you adjust the setting and time. There’s one catch: in Breaking Bad, we’re watching Walter White begin as a high school teacher and slowly work his way into a crime empire. In Boardwalk, we watch Nucky Thompson slowly but surely lose his. They show the same character at two very crucial and inevitable points in his life: the rise and the fall. It’s the classic hero story, albeit the word “hero” is used very loosely.
The parallels between Jimmy and Jesse are fascinating, as well. I’ve always noticed similarities between the two, but I realized that the main differences aren’t in the characters themselves, but how Walter and Nucky - their mentors/enemies - view them. In the beginning of Breaking Bad, Walter needs Jesse. He approaches Jesse to cook meth, not the other way around. But as their relationship grows and the world around them complicates, their dynamic slowly shifts from semi-equals to Walter being Jesse’s boss, essentially. In season four, Jesse nearly usurps Walt - until he realizes that he truly does need Walt now.
In contrast, by the end of Boardwalk Empire’s second season, it’s very obvious what the relationship has done to both men. Nucky clearly doesn’t need Jimmy anymore (as evidenced by his execution of his former companion), and Jimmy thinks he doesn’t need Nucky, until the men he’s fall in with prove to be more questionable than he’d like. He turns to Nucky, but the naïvety that weakens Walt is nowhere to be found in Nucky. He kills Jimmy, in cold blood, and it’s in this that I realize that Jimmy is probably the last in a long line of Jimmies. There have been lots of…well, I don’t know what to call them. I’ll go with worker-son. It suits the relationship best, even if it does come across a little Big Love-y. Nucky’s likely had scads of worker-sons in between Jesse and Jimmy, and it’s in this that he’s become to cynical towards them.
There’s been lots of speculation as to where Walt began his decline in morality (yet rise in the crime world), and I agree with the majority - he begins his transformation when he kills Jane, Jesse’s girlfriend in season two, but he doesn’t realize it until the brilliant “I am the one who knocks” speech in season four. That means he goes nearly two seasons without noticing his deep, dark decline into the underworld. Nucky’s not the kind of man who would let that go unnoticed, and I noticed a lot of “I am the one who knocks” speeches made by Nucky, all with diminishing returns.
This brings us to the women in their lives: Skyler and Margaret. They compliment each other very well - Skyler is the woman who will (probably) eventually die helping her husband build his empire, and he will view Margaret as his chance for a way out. I’ve always imagined Nucky kept Margaret around not because he loved her - although I do think he’s grown very close to her - but because he saw the depths of his depravity and needed a trapdoor to redemption. It’s unclear as to whether he’ll take that road or not, but I think he likes knowing it’s there.
So there it is. My pet theory. Breaking Bad and Boardwalk Empire are absolutely brilliant, and go hand-in-hand in depicting, respectively, the rise and fall of American crime. (Boardwalk, more literally, depicts the rise of American crime - the roaring ’20s introduced organized crime to America). Just like the original trio of HBO dramas - Deadwood, The Sopranos, and The Wire - depict the rise, decline, and eventual fall of American civilization (respectively), BB and BE go hand in hand with those shows, albeit with a more focused viewfinder.